“Today, there are multiple currents competing to shape the future of peer work: a social movement vision exemplified by the heirs of the psychiatric survivors; an increasingly clinical model reflecting how the role has been institutionalized in practice; and the MAHA vision that many people, and not always reluctantly, are embracing. Second-generation theory seeks to articulate a fourth position. It would not choose between movement and institution, or between lived experience and evidence, but theorize their tensions and build on the possibilities created by their intersection. The conversation is only beginning. We invite you to join us as we try to pose some initial questions.” – Jon Soske, Towards Second Generation Theories of Peer Support
These remarks from yesterday’s powerful session at the National Conference on Addiction Recovery Science on the future of the peer workforce and associated movement are insightful and worth reading. The current tensions between the institutionalization of the workforce and adherence to the founding principles of two distinct models – the psychiatric survivor model and the New Recovery Advocacy Movement model – are great enough that we may lose this model altogether if we as peers and members of this workforce can’t adapt faster than the systems who are currently doing the adapting for us.
The reality is that we have to let go of some of the foundations of these original models in order to retain some level of control over the shape of our movements.
Many movements before us have had to make significant adaptations to be effective. What originated as abolition to end slavery became the Civil Rights Movement to respond to the reality of the New Jim Crow, and that has adapted yet again to focus on things like prison and housing reform or more recently, the Black Lives Matter movement. The foundational goals of each of these iterations has been the same but many of the strategies, tools, and implementation models have changed significantly to meet each moment.
We must also reckon with each movement’s commitment to being divergent models. We may not be able to continue making them so distinct if we are to rise to the need of the current moment. This moment calls us to push back against the cooption and the distortion of our work and principles by self-serving systems whose primary goals are to withhold and retain power and resources or serve political movements.
We are going to have to work together if we are to fight this extremely powerful system: Mental health models, substance use recovery models, and harm reduction models of the peer workforce and advocacy movements.
We can and should honor what our founders envisioned. We can and should call back to their intentions and principles to help inform and shape us today. But we must also be willing to let go and envision a new model and definitions of what peers and the peer workforce need to be in order to retain our power as an independent entity outside of systems that can function effectively while working with systems, and protect ourselves and the community members we’re here to support.
This movement forward must also include a critical step we should not overlook: mourning what the movements originally envisioned, and how far they’ve brought us. Without this acknowledgment, we risk our unity.